There is No Fate But What We Make: India's Dark Secret

Friday, September 23, 2005

India's Dark Secret

Every nation has its holy cows. Persons and Institutes revered
by all citizens without exception. No one questions them.
Indian army is one such institute. It's getting away with
egregious blunders, profligacy and abuse.
No one is questioning it. All in the name of "national interest".
While nation ruled by dictatorships can be excused but why is
it that Indians, proud of its pluralist views, never
ask uncomfortable questions about its army.
Here are my peeves about our national army.

First, we have too large an army. This may sound foolish
because the army is fighting battles against separatists,
and of course, the "sent from across the border" terrorists
in Kashmir.The fundamental problem is india's insistence
on solving political problems militarily. India has always
been like this -
hyderabad, goa, north east, bhindrawale, kashmir ...
you name it.
We can't think of one political problem that India has solved
using diplomacy and political acumen. India had time from
1948 to1989 to settle the kashmir in a fair and peaceful way.
There was no popular demand for "azaadi" before. In 1965,
when Pakistan sent its soldiers to Kashmir hoping to incite
unrest, not a single kashmiri cooperated. On many instances
the locals promptly reported outsiders. Why did India not
capitalize on the opportunities ? Right upto the 1987 elections,
which the central government shamelessly rigged, political
solution was possible. Having blundered again and again,
India is now trying to ruthlessly suppress the militants.
So overwhelming is the force that India is applying, that it
is using more than a hundred thousand troops in the valley
to tackle a few thousand militants.

Take the north-east. We had a golden opportunity in 1947
to integrate these states into the mainstream. The popular
sentiment was ready for it. But given that India's central
leadership has always found it hard to think for people
beyond the gangetic valley, it was not surprising that we
managed to alienate the people in those regions. If only we
studied the history of these people, we could have realized
that delhi's rule over this region has always been tenuous.
The mighty mughal army could not establish control over
this area, in spite of trying for 300 years. Trying to
accomplish this with a few decades of Indian army is
repeating a folly. We should try political options.

We now have nuclear weapons. Doesn't this increase
our sense of security ? Why has it not resulted in a
decrease in theexpenditure on the army ?
On the contrary, the defense budget has seen steep
hikes. And this has been done by none other than
P C Chidambaram, a minister whom urban middle class
seems to eulogize as the panacea of all ills.

I have an inkling why the budget never goes down.
We keep importing arms and ammunitions. Who is
benefiting from this ? There are myriad middlemen
who get cuts from defense deals. And this cannot be
happening without the connivance of atleast a section
of army top brass. Bofors and the coffin cases came
out in the open. But every defense deal steals money
from the tax paying citizens. Then there are petty
thefts and pilferage - kerosene being sold outside.
Ration and other items marked for soldiers are
easily available inthe market. The MES (Military
Engineering Service) contracts are so notorious
for corruption that it is euphemistically called
the "10 percent" service. The Army Supply
Corps (ASC) goes by the appellation of
"Atta Sugar Chor" !
Need we see more ?

A large part of the army stays occupied
maintaining itself - serving other soldiers
(barbers, medics, priests etc). While this
can be justified, do we need soldiers running errands
for officers. These soldiers called "batmans" (sic)
are a throwback to the times of british occupation
when the Indians used to do menial jobs for
the british officers.

These are the steps that should be taken to fix the
current situation :
- Use our democratic and pluralistic spirit to solve
political problems with dialog and political process.
Reduce military present and create an atmosphere
for dialogue. A happy population proud to be part
of the nation is the best defense.
- Decrease army headcount by 50%.
Augment the national army by creating a strong
volunteer army that can be called upon duty at a
short notice. This will need NCC to be upgraded.
- Decrease the defense budget. Decrease the
import and stockpiling of arms.

Jai Hind


At Monday, October 31, 2005 12:49:00 AM, Anonymous Tarun said...

Much to think about. I agree that this military paranoia is foolish and a waste.
But an immediate problem on reducing defence expenditure would be unemployment. How could we deal with this? India is already overpopulated and people have to struggle to gain skills needed for professional employment.

At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 4:10:00 AM, Anonymous Orion said...

I don't see many replies to the comments. Say why??

At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 4:42:00 AM, Blogger Charu Majumdar said...

yes, military spending is a waste..
can and should be reduced..
maintaining a large standing army
to create employment is foolish.
economics doesn't work that way, not
in capitalism anyway.
Once upon a time, lakhs of people
to work as telephone operators. With
computerization all these jobs went
away. We didn't stop computerization
and mechanization to keep the jobs,
did we ? People *must* reskill and
find employment in changing
circumstances. Protectionism is not
the solution. Beyond creating a
level playing field, it is NOT
government's responsibility to create jobs.
That's the responsibility of the industry.
Government should only create
conditions favourable to industry.
No more, no less.

" India is already overpopulated and people have to struggle to gain skills needed for professional employment."

If population is the problem, it
should be tackled by promoting
literacy (specially women's literacy). If people have to struggle to gain skills, that's
exactly how it should be. No
spoon feeding by government.
Struggle and find employment.

At Sunday, November 06, 2005 8:29:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

India needs strong Military to Fight Pakistan and china. But !

you may be right! In Delhi, they think it is Hindia , and include only Hindi speaking people. They have no consideration at all for other languages. They are the senseless fascist dickheads.

Policies in Delhi are made based on personal will and wish not on a wider consensus. Hindu way of doing things is reflecting here.

what can you expect from a snake charmer anyway ?

At Monday, May 08, 2006 12:23:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

u r over confident and un informed but a trye patirot u have to feel the real problems of india like faulty governing system multi party democracy which divide indian on each basis military expenditure should be increase because we got nothing against our secularis attitude no community in india is loyal to hindhs and we try lvel hard to coperate them and now we not entertain ther foolish demands of sepration this all is don by isi muslim world to weeakend hidhu world

At Monday, May 08, 2006 12:29:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

pls contact me 09891560094 varun kaushik i am patriot but don;t no what to for a countary


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home